Football Management

Commentary on the management of over 160 English football clubs by Dr John Beech, winner of the FSF Writer of the Year Award 2009/10 Twitter: @JohnBeech Curator of! Football Finance

The fate of resurrectionist clubs

Posted by John Beech on July 6, 2009

I’m not sure what it is that draws me to following the fate of resurrectionist clubs. Perhaps it’s just the curiosity of seeing whether the new club can make a better fist of it than its predecessor. Maybe it’s the delayed gratification of following their success or failure over a number of seasons. No matter the reason, I am currently working on a research project investigating the determinants of their fate.

A number of them have featured during the 2008/09 season, some for the right reasons, some not. The success stories have undoubtedly been AFC Wimbledon, about to play in the Conference National, and FC United of Manchester (I count them as a resurrectionist club even though their predecessor is not actually defunct!). Both enjoy healthy inherited fanbases and both are well run, so their success was predictable.

Accrington Stanley (who are a resurrection of what was itself a resurrection club) has faced problems, notably a winding-up order from HMRC, narrowly avoided by a takeover (1). Could it just be that the proximity of Blackburn and Burnley mean a club in Accrington is always on a hiding to nothing in the senior divisions?

Newport AFC faced the worst of problems when they reformed from the ashes of Newport County – they could only find a home at Moreton-in-the-March, and, after a brief return home, at the marginally closer Gloucester. Narrowly escaping expulsion from the English pyramid, they have fought their way back as far as the Conference South, just one tier below the point which Newport County was expelled from. A recently revitalised Supporters Trust may well see them eventually get back to whence they came.

The last club to be resurrected in the pre-commercialised era was Maidstone. Their exile was more traumatic than even Newport’s – after 15 years they are still not playing back in Maidstone, a situation which becomes more and more problematic as the years go by. Will the hoped for return bring back more Maidstone fans than lose Sittingbourne (where they currently play) fans? Kent seems a particularly difficult county in which a football club can thrive. Other clubs which have faced insolvency events over the years include Dover, Folkestone Town, Gillingham, and Margate. This season Ashford Town have failed to pay players amid talk of Administration, and Folkestone Invicta (resurrection of Folkestone Town) are dangerously close to calling in the Administrator.

Another club to make the news this season is AFC Scarborough, wound up with debts of £2.5m just over two years ago. Again in exile, they plan to return to Scarborough, from Bridlington (2). A relatively short distance (17 miles) for a relatively short period should not dent their attendance.

Down the coast at Boston, there was good news earlier in the season – the club was allowed to keep cup competition prize money (3), a rare case of a governing body pragmatically distinguishing between different regimes at a club.

Further down, at Canvey Island, who were decimated by the withdrawal of benefactor Jeff King in 2005, the club continues to claw its way back to whence it came.

Worst news was at Hornchurch, where the club, only re-formed in 2005 following the collapse of their backers, has been forced into Administration (4). Details of these latest problems are scant, and if any reader can provide some I’d be very grateful.

7 Responses to “The fate of resurrectionist clubs”

  1. Kevin Rye said

    John – the reformed Scarborough is actually Scarborough Athletic. Sorry to be a pedant :o)

  2. John Beech said

    Indeed it is. Be proud to be a pedant!

    • John Beech said

      And sincere apologies to all Seadogs fans (1) too. I’ve learned my lesson – Scarborough ATHLETIC, Scarborough ATHLETIC, Scarborough ATHLETIC. But I’m not ‘press’, just an errant academic.

  3. John Beech said

    I should also have mentioned Aldershot Town as having been in the news this last season. Having fought their way back to Tier 4 after 15 years, they found themselves short of cash to enter the transfer market (1 and 2). The latest development is that fans have set up a player fund to aid the club (3). While is thoroughly commendable in principle and speaks volumes for the fans’ support, I wonder whether it is not a slightly risky approach. If the club becomes dependent on such largesse, it hardly helps in building in a sustainable business model unless fans are prepared for ever to ‘sub the club’.

  4. […] by John Beech on July 7, 2009 In a comment to a posting yesterday (1) I referred to what I call ’subbing the club’. At Aldershot Town fans have set up a […]

  5. John Beech said

    Kevin Rye’s 8th July posting on the Supporters Direct blog is well worth a read (click here).

  6. […] my earlier posting on The fate of resurrectionist clubs (1), I looked at FC United of Manchester although their predecessor was alive and not doing too badly […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: